Space Optics

Lambda Research software in space and astronomy projects

In space there is no servicing, no swapping of a lens, and no second attempt. A telescope, camera, or lidar has to work correctly from the first power-up in orbit, and stray light that could be measured and reduced on Earth can destroy the contrast of an entire instrument in space. That is why Lambda Research software, especially TracePro and OSLO, has appeared for years in NASA projects and other space missions.

Lambda Research software in space and astronomy projects
Request a quote Start a trial

When we talk about space optics, we usually think of huge mirrors and spectacular images. Behind every such instrument, however, are hundreds of hours of work on less visible things: whether light from the Moon will reach the detector, whether the black coating of the housing really absorbs rather than reflects, and whether manufacturing tolerances will allow the required image quality after assembly and rocket launch.

In this area, Lambda Research tools have a unique history. TracePro grew out of NASA contracts, and OSLO is a classical program for designing optical systems, from objectives to telescopes. Below we show what is known about their space applications from publicly available sources, and why these two programs fit the problems of space optics so well.

Why space optics is different

A space instrument works in conditions that cannot be fully reproduced on Earth. It cannot be fixed after launch, and every kilogram and every element has its price. At the same time, the requirements are extreme: observation of very faint sources, a wide temperature range, strong radiation, and a long operating time without maintenance.

That is why, already at the design stage, you have to answer questions that in a typical industrial device can be postponed until the prototype:

  • how much of the light from a bright source outside the field of view will reach the detector,
  • whether mechanical surfaces and their coatings really limit reflections,
  • what the paths of multiple reflections and ghost images look like,
  • how manufacturing and assembly deviations will affect image quality,
  • whether the analysis result is reliable, given that there is no second attempt.

Stray light: the main enemy of astronomical instruments

Stray light is light that reaches the detector by a path other than the planned one: through reflections from mounts, scattering on edges, multiple reflections in lenses, or surfaces with an imperfect finish. In astronomical instruments this is particularly severe, because the observed object can be orders of magnitude fainter than a bright source nearby, such as the Sun, the Earth, or the Moon.

In its article on stray light analysis in satellites, Lambda Research describes the James Webb Space Telescope as an example of an instrument that required careful design to limit light from the Sun, the Earth, and the Moon at the L2 Lagrange point. You can find more about the phenomenon itself and its analysis in the article Stray light analysis: what it is.

Where TracePro came from: the beginnings at NASA

The history of TracePro is unusual for commercial software. According to NASA Spinoff, in 1992-1993 Lambda Research received SBIR (Small Business Innovation Research) contracts from the Jet Propulsion Laboratory whose goal was to create a program for stray light analysis. In 1995, a second SBIR contract followed, from the Goddard Space Flight Center, concerning the modeling of electro-optical systems.

The result of this work was a program that still develops today as a non-sequential Monte Carlo ray tracing tool, combining mechanical geometry, optics, surface properties, and detectors in a single model.

Terra and MISR: the first imager designed with TracePro

The first imaging instrument designed with the help of TracePro that NASA Spinoff mentions was MISR (Multi-angle Imaging SpectroRadiometer) on the Terra satellite, launched in 1999. JPL optical engineer Tolis Deslis used the program to predict the behavior of stray light, acknowledging that such multiple reflections cannot be traced by hand.

According to the same publication, the simulation result had a concrete design consequence: a bare aluminum housing was replaced with a light-absorbing coating. It is a good example of what stray light analysis means in practice. It is not a nice picture of an irradiance distribution, but a decision about the material and finish of a specific element of the instrument.

James Webb Space Telescope: independent verification of stray light

James Webb Space Telescope with its primary mirror fully deployed during testing in 2020

The James Webb Space Telescope with its primary mirror fully deployed during testing in 2020. Photo: NASA/Chris Gunn.

The most famous example concerns the James Webb Space Telescope. According to NASA Spinoff, Dennis Skelton of Sigma Space, a contractor working with the Goddard Space Flight Center, used TracePro to confirm the stray light analyses performed by Ball Aerospace. The two analyses gave results that agreed to within about 20 percent.

It is worth noting how this example should be read. TracePro was not the tool that designed the telescope here. It was an independent check of a critical analysis, in which a mistake could have meant an instrument with lower contrast, impossible to correct after launch. This kind of double confirmation of a result with different tools and by different teams is standard in large space projects, and in the case described TracePro played exactly this role.

Lambda Research also lists JWST on its aerospace and defense applications page as a project in which TracePro and OSLO contributed to improving the optical performance of the instrument. That page is marketing in nature and gives no details or results, so for the sake of rigor we rely on the NASA Spinoff description.

Other missions in which TracePro appears

NASA Spinoff also lists other instruments and missions in which TracePro was used. Five of them are shown below.

Pancam: the cameras of the Spirit and Opportunity rovers

The Pancam panoramic camera of the Opportunity Mars rover

The Pancam panoramic camera of the Opportunity Mars rover, used to capture detailed panoramas of the Martian surface. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/Cornell/ASU.

LORRI: the camera of the New Horizons probe

LORRI, the telescopic camera of the New Horizons probe

LORRI (Long Range Reconnaissance Imager) - the telescopic camera of the New Horizons probe, designed to take high-resolution images of distant objects in the Solar System. Credit: NASA.

GALEX: an ultraviolet space telescope

The Galaxy Evolution Explorer (GALEX), a NASA space telescope

The Galaxy Evolution Explorer (GALEX) - a NASA space telescope designed to observe the Universe in ultraviolet light. Credit: NASA.

GEDI: a lidar on the International Space Station

GEDI, a laser instrument on the International Space Station

GEDI (Global Ecosystem Dynamics Investigation) - a laser instrument mounted on the International Space Station, used to measure the three-dimensional structure of forests and the Earth's surface. Credit: NASA.

ATLAS: the laser altimeter of the ICESat-2 satellite

Assembly of the ATLAS instrument of the ICESat-2 satellite

ATLAS (Advanced Topographic Laser Altimeter System) - the laser altimeter of the ICESat-2 satellite, which uses laser pulses to measure the height of ice, land, vegetation, and other elements of the Earth's surface. Credit: NASA.

In its materials, Lambda Research adds, among others, the Curiosity rover, the Mars Climate Sounder, the Moon Mineralogy Mapper, and the Lunar Orbiter Laser Altimeter. This is a list that indicates the range of applications, from imaging optics, through telescopes, to lidars and altimeters, that is, instruments in which unwanted light and mechanical geometry decide the quality of the measurement.

OSLO: designing the optics of a telescope and an instrument

If TracePro answers the question of where light goes in a real instrument, then OSLO answers the question of what the optical system itself should look like. In a telescope or space instrument project this means, among other things:

  • selecting the arrangement of mirrors or lenses and optimizing it,
  • analyzing aberrations and image quality across the whole field of view,
  • assessing the effect of manufacturing and assembly deviations on the result,
  • designing collimating, compensating, and relay systems inside the instrument.

Tolerance analysis, described in the article Tolerance analysis of optical systems in OSLO, is particularly important here. In space there is no way to readjust the system after assembly in orbit, so the question "what if an element is manufactured with a deviation?" has to be asked before the optics are made.

What TracePro offers in a space instrument project

TracePro lets you build a 3D model of the whole instrument: the optical system, mounts, baffles, housing, and detector. You can assign surface and material properties to this model and then trace how light actually reaches the detector. According to Lambda Research, this includes, among other things:

  • design and evaluation of baffles and shields limiting light from outside the field of view,
  • analysis of scattering and multiple reflections on mechanical surfaces,
  • analysis of ghost images in lens systems,
  • modeling of polarization and thermal effects,
  • import of geometry from CAD systems.

Coatings come on top of that. The absorbing black coatings inside the instrument and the anti-reflection coatings on the optics have a direct effect on the level of stray light, and TracePro lets you define a thin-film stack on an element's surface in the solid model. We describe this in more detail in the article Thin-film coating design in optical engineering.

Example workflow for a space or astronomical instrument

1. Define the observation requirements

Determine what objects the instrument is to observe, what range of off-axis angles poses a threat (the Sun, the Earth, the Moon), and what level of stray light is acceptable.

2. Design the optical system in OSLO

Optimize the mirrors or lenses and check the aberrations and image quality across the whole field.

3. Perform a tolerance analysis

Check how manufacturing and assembly deviations affect the required image quality, and establish which parameters are critical.

4. Build a 3D model of the instrument in TracePro

Add the mounts, baffles, housing, and detector, and define the surfaces and their scattering and reflection properties.

5. Analyze the paths of unwanted light

Run a simulation for sources outside the field of view at various angles and check which light paths reach the detector and which elements contribute the most.

6. Introduce design corrections

Modify the baffle geometry, the shape of the mounts, or the surface finish, and check the effect of each change on the result, as in the described example from the Terra mission.

7. Correlate the model with measurement

Compare the model with measurements of real surfaces and coating samples and, if possible, with an independent analysis by a second team or tool.

Which Lambda Research tool for which task

Task Tool
Design of the mirror or lens system of a telescope OSLO
Optimization and aberration analysis OSLO
Manufacturing and assembly tolerance analysis OSLO
Stray light and out-of-field light analysis TracePro
Design of baffles and shields TracePro
Ghost images and multiple reflections TracePro
Thin-film coatings on a surface in a 3D model TracePro
Model of the whole instrument with mechanics and detector TracePro

The most common mistakes in space optics analysis

Trusting a single analysis

Since there is no second attempt, key results, such as the stray light level, are worth confirming independently, as was done for JWST.

Ideal surfaces

Assuming that a black coating absorbs all the light leads to underestimated predictions. Real surfaces scatter and reflect, and the model should account for this.

Analyzing the optics without the mechanics

Mounts, baffles, and the housing are part of the optical path if they can reflect or scatter light. Designing the optics alone in OSLO does not replace analyzing the whole instrument in TracePro.

Skipping tolerances

A system that works perfectly in the nominal model may not meet the requirements after real manufacturing and assembly.

Analyzing only the optical axis

In astronomical instruments the greatest threat is often light from outside the field of view, so the analysis must cover a wide range of off-axis angles.

Summary

The NASA examples show the role Lambda Research software plays in space optics. TracePro grew out of SBIR contracts with JPL and Goddard, helped in the design of the MISR instrument on the Terra satellite, and in the case of the James Webb Space Telescope served as an independent confirmation of the stray light analyses performed by Ball Aerospace. Among the instruments for which, according to NASA, it was used are also the rover cameras, LORRI, GALEX, GEDI, and ATLAS. OSLO completes the picture as a program for designing and optimizing the optics themselves and for analyzing their tolerances.

For the designer of astronomical instruments, satellite cameras, or lidars, a simple conclusion follows. Optical design, stray light analysis, and tolerance analysis should be carried out together, on a shared model, before the instrument leaves the workshop. This is exactly what the OSLO and TracePro pair is for.

Resources and sources

History of TracePro, the SBIR contracts with JPL and Goddard, and applications in NASA missions: NASA Spinoff: Information Technology

Article on the use of TracePro in NASA missions, including the verification of stray light analyses for JWST: Tech Briefs: Light Analysis Software Explodes Across Industries

Analysis of stray light in satellite optical systems: Lambda Research: Analysis of Stray Light in Satellite Optical Systems Using TracePro

Applications of TracePro and OSLO in aerospace, defense, and space: Lambda Research: Aerospace and Defense Projects with TracePro

Frequently asked questions
Lambda Research software in space and astronomy projects

Was Lambda Research software used in the James Webb Space Telescope project?

Yes, but its role should be described precisely. According to a NASA Spinoff publication, an engineer working with the Goddard Space Flight Center used TracePro to confirm the stray light analyses performed by Ball Aerospace for JWST, and the results of the two analyses agreed to within about 20 percent. Lambda Research also lists JWST among the projects in which TracePro and OSLO were used.

Where did the TracePro software come from?

TracePro grew out of SBIR (Small Business Innovation Research) contracts with NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory in 1992-1993, whose goal was to create a program for stray light analysis. In 1995, Lambda Research received another SBIR contract, from the Goddard Space Flight Center, for modeling electro-optical systems.

What is the difference between the roles of OSLO and TracePro in a telescope or space instrument project?

OSLO is used to design and optimize the optics themselves: the arrangement of mirrors or lenses, aberrations, and tolerances. TracePro analyzes the whole instrument as a 3D model with mechanics, coatings, and scattering, that is, where light goes outside the ideal optical path, including stray light.

Why is stray light so dangerous in space instruments?

Astronomical instruments often observe objects thousands of times fainter than a bright source near the field of view, such as the Sun, the Earth, or the Moon. Even a small fraction of the light from such a source, scattered on edges, mounts, or contamination and reaching the detector, can obscure the object the instrument is meant to see.

Does simulation replace testing the instrument before launch?

No. Simulation lets you make design decisions early and check many variants, but its results should be correlated with measurements of real surfaces, coatings, and components. A good example is the JWST approach, where the result of one tool was confirmed by an independent analysis from a second team.

What surface data is needed for a reliable stray light analysis?

The most important are the scattering and reflection properties of surfaces, including absorbing mechanical coatings, and the geometry of elements such as mounts, baffles, and the housing. The better the model reflects real materials and surface finish, the more reliable the predicted path of unwanted light.

Do such tools make sense only for large space missions?

No. The same problems, such as stray light, coatings, tolerances, or ghost images, occur in satellite cameras, ground-based telescopes, measuring instruments, and lidars. TracePro and OSLO are commercially available programs, and their origin in NASA projects shows the conditions in which they were developed.

Ready to check it on your own project?

Ask our engineers for a tailored quote or start a free trial today.

Request a quote Start a trial

← All articles